PDA

View Full Version : great reply to Lee's blog


GS
June 8th, 2006, 07:30 AM
I love XM's non-bubble gum approach to counter typical FM commercial
radio... as detailed in this blog:


Lee Abrams' Blog

Monday, June 05, 2006
MORE FROM THE XM PLAYBOOK

We are not "there" yet...it takes time, but here are a few things we
preach. Do we deliver? Not always? Do we try? Hell yeah. Why am I
telling people outside of the building about these "secrets"? Because
if someone thinks like this--we want to know. Here are a few items----

AFDI: (Actually Fucking Doing It)The battle call. The center of our
programming universe. Instead of researching EVERYthing, commitees and
"we can't do that"...the idea is to actually EXECUTE on the ideas that
are created.

SWAGGER: The way we carry ourselves on and off the air. An air of
confidence based on AFDI and collective ego. Radio has been beaten up
by other media--time to fight back.

MINUTE BY MINUTE: The musical bottom line. Forget Depth. Forget Tight.
If you, at any given point in time (minute by minute) are playing a
cool song, you will win the music battle.

ARTIST OWNERSHIP: Re-claiming artists. Bringing them back to radio. XM
Radio.
Radio has given up on trying to own artists...given up to MTV, Print
and Cable. XM must bring artists back to radio.

CELEBRATION: We don't simply "play" important music. We celebrate it.
A Gospel Church may celebrate the Lord...well, we’re the Gospel Church
of music.

AUTHENTICITY: In a plastic world, we are the real deal. No
compromises. Ward Cleaver and Manny Malig run XMLM our Metal channel.
They bleed metal, and listeners will hear and respect that.

SONICS: It's the evolution of "Imaging"...it's the SOUND of your
channel. Don't think bumpers & promos. Think beyond that.....it's all
about a whole sonic environment you create.

SONIC DENSITY: The intensity and frequency of sonic pieces.

CAUSE I WANT TO: Doing things on air, "because you feel like
it"...maybe a break in Swahili....or Pig Latin.....

HUMVEE CRASHING: The art of crashing an R/C humvee into the wall
during an important meeting. XM must live and breathe in the hallways
too!

NATIONAL & PROUD OF IT: Local radio is quaint....National radio is the
future.

SUPRISE ATTACKING: Wanna mess up the competitors mind: Run a Top 5,000
three weeks BEFORE Memorial Day. You will screw up their system...

24 HOUR MORNING SHOW: There is no morning. We don't shut down at 10am.
We are always on.

JUST DO IT!: No bragging...no cheezy claims . No "Most Music" "Best
Mix" "Never a Bad Song"........Those claims have no credibility. Just
deliver the goods and our fans will know.

FANS: To Ad Sales they're listeners....to Marketing they're
customers...to us: They're Fans. Treat listeners like Fans. Think like
a Fan. This is show business. Relating to listeners as numbers is
fine---for the sales people.

MUSICAL CONFIDENCE: Delivering the goods musically. Not lying about
how musical we are...actually delivering music to the point where
listeners believe we're in it for "The Passion not the Cash". Cash is
a nice reward if we make people happy.


BIBLE OF MUSIC: Your station is the center of your music's' universe.
You have the chart. You have the answers. You are in command. You must
deliver. You must deliver. You must deliver. MTV, Rolling Stone,
Spin...fine entities, but YOU must own the charts, the info,
etc...listeners must come to YOU to know what's going on musically.

CINEMATIC RADIO: The sound of your station is more like a wide screen
movie soundtrack than a radio station. You should close your eyes and
your sonics ignite with cinematic brilliance. Even News....Even
Classical...no format is exempt from creating cinematic magic between
the songs.

BAGGAGE: Old radio thinking. There's allot of radio thinking that's
timeless...like playing the best songs...but there's a king bong of
baggage too....lose it.


ER: Bigg-ER.....Badd-ER....Intense-ER. Think like Walt Disney did in
the 50’s..."ER". Rides were fastER, parks were cleanER, etc…

OTT: Over-the-Top. Subtle sucks. Want to cut through the Internet,
AM/FM, print, TV etc....well, you ain't gonna do it unless you do
everything OTT

TOP DOWN SOUND: There is nothing more magical than driving down a
freeway at 100mph...top down...great station blasting at top volume!
XM will bring this experience back to Americans. Think about this
experience as you program. It's more than great songs...it's the whole
package...it's the essence of "The XM Sound"

ECCENTRIC...ALL THE WAY TO THE BANK: Doctors, Repairmen, Cops should
not be eccentric! We should be....all the way to the bank. Smart
eccentrics make the great art.

WRCX: (or any other station we worked at): Lose it. Kill it from the
memory. These stations are NOT the standard to compare. If we are to
compare the XM Sound to something, make it a Kubrick movie......a
Beatle epic.....a Radiohead track. NOT radio stations we used to work
at.

CREATIVE BATTING AVERAGE: % of ideas you come up with that work. 300
Average is All-Star. Ya gotta take some swings to get hits.

CLICHE BUZZER: Three buzzes and sayonara. But the real cliche buzzer
is in your head.

SONIC DIVERSITY: Using the World of Sound. Not some damn production
package or pre-cut promo factory CD. USE SOUND!
Thunderstorms..static...busy streets....short wave radio
tuning....sample a TV Newscaster and repeat "In Todays News..In Todays
News..
over and over. Discover the world of sound. Use it.

VOICE DIVERSITY: Discover the world of voices. I'm mildly depressed
that Fine Tuning was the only format that at CES used foreign voices,
voices off the street, etc....
"Professional" voices are fine...but you're only using 2% of the
voices out there.
There is magic in the human voice. There is cliche' in the radio
voice!!!

THE GEORGE MARTIN GENE: Everyone has it. Activate it. It's the gene
that tells you to diversify your sound. There are no rules. Our Reggae
channel can have signatures that combine Gregorian Chants with Steel
Drums. WE MUST RE-INVENT THE WAY RADIO SOUNDS. There are no barriers
except your imagination.

CONVENIENCE HIRES: It's only natural, and often correct to bring in
people you know and trust. But, it's also natural to bring in people
who are convenient. We must hire only the brilliant.

IT FACTOR: Some people got "it"...some don't. If you don't get
"it"....please see me asap

MOUTH OF AMERICA: XM should sound like America. From hicks in
Mississippi to Brothers in Chicago to Mothers in San Francisco to
Yuppies in St. Louis. We must open the phones to reflect the magic of
National Radio.

MOOD/RELIABLE: Mood listeners tune you in when they're in the
mood...Reliable listeners never tune you out. That's the secret to
rating success (or satisfaction in our case). The only way to achieve
this balance is to never compromise....stay pure....play "your"
hits...don't fear tune out. In other words: Do your thing, but do it
brilliantly and consistently.

STAR WARS: Those goofy laser sounds that must die

THE CHUCK VAN ROGERS FACTOR: OK, if you have a radio name and don't
want to change it...fine. Especially if you've had it for years... But
if you do want to change it..Go for it! Mike O'Morgan (whoever he is)
just reeks of fake, old, tired radio. This is Show-biz. Like the WWF,
who's gonna win the bout? Bob Stevens or The Masked Killer from Mars.
Again, not a requirement, but
cool names, real names (Frank Schmutzbaum is cooler than Mark James)
or Nicknames that are "XM" are great. Why does radio have this thing
with TWO first names?? Robert Stevens, Steven Roberts, Michael
Williams, William Michaels?

PAPER TIME vs REAL TIME: On one of our deeper formats we'll tend to
look at two lists: A 20,000 title list and an 10000 title list. 10000
probably makes more sense...though on paper 20,000 looks better or 200
if you’re an old school research guy. This is the difference between
paper and real-time listening.The point is separating paper from
reality.

TODD STORZ: The creator of Top 40 on Real-Time listening: Just when
DJs are going to strike because_____is still on the playlist is the
same time Mama is learning to hum the verse". The point: Paper Time
vs. Real Time. Think like a listener/fan not a DJ in terms of music
rotation.

CAN'T UNDERSTAND THE FUTURE UNTIL YOU UNDERSTAND THE PAST: An appetite
to learn about the history of contemporary radio. If you weren't
there, learning about the great battles will arm you with powerful
knowledge.

THE LETTERMAN FACTOR: Disco Demolition, Hit This Plane & Win $5,000,
Snow Sharks, and other stunts are pure America. People love it. The
more radio versions of "Stupid Pet Tricks" we create, the better we'll
be….on the RIGHT channel of course.


THE CULTURALLY CHALLENGED: We must never be "too hip for the room". We
target everyone from musical elitists to the culturally challenged.
KNOW YOUR PLACE. Sophisticated humor on "America" is as bad as stupid
contests on XM Classics. Knowing WHERE the edhe is and delivering
right on it is an art.

WARPED: A way of looking at things. Akin to eccentric. If we can take
an angle and warp it, we've done our job. Clapton warped his guitar in
'67 by using a wah-wah pedal....Warping is taking a sound or idea and
modifying it to "the XM Sound"

SMELL THE SPEAKERS: Our formats should be SO sonically dense...SO
pure..so authentic, that they should smell. Smell the speakers during
Frank's Place and it's martinis, an old deck of cards and Sammy Davis
Junior’s cologne.

AUTHENTICITY: XM is to FM what EPCOT is to Reality. We aren't a model
of the real thing....we ARE the real thing.

PURITY: Every format must be pure. There's magic in what you DON'T
hear. You'll hear Deep Tracks and never hear Foreigner...You'll hear
BONEYARD and never hear Steven Stills, etc.....We must avoid
Good-Good------Good-----, meaning a few "correct songs" then a ----
(or misplaced) song. Every song will get played SOMEWHERE on the XM
band...the key is in purity so each song happens where it's meant to
happen.

YELLOW PAD: Everyone should be filling these up with ideas. Document
your dreams.

AS ACCESSABLE AS POSSIBLE WITHOUT LOSING LISTENER CONFIDENCE: The goal
shouldn't be how "deep" can I go. It should be how "far" can I go
WITHOUT LOSING listener confidence. It's a magic zone where you reach
the most listeners and satisfy them all simultaneously. Too commercial
and there goes satisfaction...too deep and there goes the volume of
fans.

WHACK FACTOR: "Where in hell did these guys come up with
that!"....thats what listeners should often think.

AVERAGE SUCKS/EXTREME RULES: Ever been to Ben's Chili Parlor down the
road?
It is a dive...a dump....and it's magical. It's extreme. Give me Ben's
over a nice clean Denny's anytime!! The point: Amazingly good or
Amazingly bad---who cares, as long as it's amazing. Anything but
average!!!!

2001FACTOR: Pre 2001 (the movie), all Sci-Fi was goofy robots crushing
Tokyo. Then 2001 reinvented Sci-Fi. Lush Space Scapes...Classical
Music....a whole new approach. It changed Sci-Fi forever. No "Help Me
Will Robinson cliches" no spooky Theramin sound effects.(though those
are kinda cool in a campy way) THAT is how we must change radio sound.
It's happening in publishing. It’s happening in video…radio is next—if
we let it happen

THE MILLIONAIRE FACTOR: Like the TV show completely re-invented game
shows...we must completely re-invent radio. It ain't evolution...it's
revolution.

EMPATHY: Walking the halls, I'll often hear how "Stairway to Heaven"
and Creed really suck. Well, if those aren't part of your potential
playlist...cool..they suck. BUT---if these belong on your list, you
need to learn empathy, because these are major. In 1970, I was a hard
core Prog Rock fan, but worked at an early FM Top 40 where we
"celebrated" Donny Osmond. I learned there, the importance of empathy.
I hated that ----, but learned how and why it worked, and never whined
about a song again. Even, neutral programming via understanding why
things(songs/artists) work.

ENVIRONMENT: Song environment is key. Stairway next to BTO & Doobie
Brothers is a snooze, but next to Traffic and a cool Hendrix track,
the songs' magic can emerge. That's a great thing about XM: Even the
most tired "great" popular songs can live on a format where they can
find new life by what they're surrounded by.

NOTHING IS SACRED: We urge you to re-think EVERYTHING. Many things are
indeed evergreen, but Struber must be commended for re-thinking the
6-10/10-3/3-7 show (never shifts!) configuration.

YOUR HITS: XM is hit driven. Every format. But the definition of a hit
differs by format..dramatically. And inour world hit isn't driven
necessarily by sales. Hits can mean:
-Song driven. The standard hit song as with Oldies formats.
-Artist Driven. as in Deep Tracks. Santana, Cream, Beatles...but not
the same three songs. Careers...not just the most played tracks.
-Novelty Driven. The Jetsons theme never charted..but its a hit
-Sound Driven. "Hit" is irrelivent..it's the "sound"...a Coltrane
piece may not be a 'hit' by traditional definition but in the frameork
of Real Jazz...it is.
-Non Radio Driven. Edgy car ads can be hits
...the point is: A Hit to XM means simply: An important song that gives
you minute by minute musical excellence. KNOW WHAT "TYPE" of hit works
for you...every format is different.

CANNON BALL/FORT THEORY: If the Fort's destruction is your goal, then
each cannonball that hits the fort is a hit. Miss the fort, it's a
stiff or an un-necessary song. More hits on the fort and the faster
the fort falls. Every song must serve a purpose, regardless of it’s
chart position or traditional hit definition.

THE RECORD BUSINESS & MUSIC PRESS ARE LOST: There are some smart
people and there are some clueless people.
That's why I constantly impress the need for you to study the genre
you serve....know your genre beyond passion. Passion is easy... but
balance that with knowledge and that's what makes you dangerous . The
reason college radio has never been a factor is because it's all
passion....
but find a college radio person who balances passion with
understanding--and there's a positively dangerous person--that we
should hire!We must continue to absorb REALITY and not simply feed off
the industry and press..

CULT/FRINGE: Every successful artist has fans who are cult or fringe.
Know the difference and program appropriately. Cultists are REALLY
into the artist....Fringe fans like the artist for the fleeting
hit(s). Doing a big Spectacular?? You're wasting your time if the fan
composition is heavy fringe.

SPECTACULARS: They enhance your image...recycle listeners and create
buzz.
Run them prime time (NOT 11pm Sunday Nights). Build them. Think about
them.
Hourly, Daily, Weekly, Monthly, Yearly. Go OTT. (Over-the-top) Repeat
them. The classic cliché is taking a cool program and burying it
because it varies from the song/dj/song format.

MEAT: When you promote...promote Meat. Never: "Great Music Coming
Up"....give 'em something to chew on: "The lost Elvis tapes found this
morning"

INCIDENTAL SOUND: Sound that just happens. Sound that "fills in the
cracks"......Audio theater.

THE XM TRAVEL AGENCY: XM Formats must take you places. Too often the
music takes you to the stars...then THUD. The reality of a "radio
break". XM must be an "out of ear" experience. Bluesville takes you to
the land of Bluesville..you ARE there. 60s on 6 takes you back to the
sixties. Fed takes you inside Fred's mind... These are truly "mind
fucks"....this is cinematic radio. Movies take you places.....XM must
take you to the same places. Never "Thud" people.....Sonic
Density.....

MOXIE: You should know what this means.

THE BIG THREE: Music....Character (Magic between the Songs)...Muscle.

THE PLAYBOOK: Terrestrial is: Get a morning show...test the
library...throw up some billboards......and everything is fine. Great
radio is complex. Develop a playbook. A gameplan. A mission beyond the
obvious.

THE TRUTH: XM tells the truth. Don't like Hendrix? Fine...don't listen
this Friday. XM 20 on 20...the top 20 over and over and over...until
you're sick of them. TELL THE TRUTH.

HUMOR: XM is about reality humor. 99.9999% of all funny things on
radio are only funny to the staff. The best humor is reality humor:
Old TV themes....real stories, etc....
Other than our Comedy channels humor is delicate....few things will
cliche you back to the FM Band than things that really aren't funny.

---: Worst than bad humor. Don't you "love" those Rock stations that
have promos "We have the biggest balls"--Oh wow--He said "balls"
Anyone who thinks, that in 2006, talking about tits is clever, go back
to FM. It's tired, stupid and annoying. The key is: If --- is an
angle, lets come up with a fresh way to approach it please.
Particularly you Rock guys.......Leave it to O&A who specilaize in it.

THE XM CREATIVE METHOD: Starts with the blueprint.....then PD builds
it....Producers and Talent decorate it. We are Frank Lloyd Wright not
Hill Valley Homes. Ever wonder why every home sorta looks the same? Me
too. If FM is safe suburbia...we are edgy Frank Lloyd Wright.

ONCE IN A LIFETIME: The opportunity to change radio window is open. If
we don't do it, we should all be shot. It'll never happen again in our
lifetimes. Remember my cycles in music chart....we are at the
beginning of another 56, 64, 69, 81, 92 up curve. we are in sync with
history.

TRADITIONAL RADIO RESEARCH SUCKS: It's flawed. If it worked, why does
every station sound like it does? Everyone does research....it's
proven it doesn't work in it's traditional form.

POPCORN CAN RADIO: An old Z-Rock trick. Huge Popcorn can was in lobby
after contents being consumed. Clever DJ decides to do entire show
from inside the popcorn can (mic and all). Now THATS radio!

STUDY SOUND: Collect it. Warp it. Radio is in last place in the sound
department. Movies are light years ahead of us in sound...TV
commercials are too, so is MTV, hell...so is NBC.
Use it. We live in a world of sound, yet sometimes we're deaf to all
but WRCX (nothing personal against WRCX employees of the past.....but
it's symbolic of "radio"..nothing more, nothing less).

SURGERY: We are operating on radio. This ain't out-patient. This is
somebody on a death bed....penecillan (research) didn't work....new
drugs (consultants) didn't work. This patient is dead unless we come
up with a radical operation.

SOUL: Radio has lost its soul...we must bring it back. A
consciousness...a spirit....a genuine desire to bring radio back to
the people...and AFDI. You must know the business side of things, but
not at the expense of your soul. What I'm saying is SO
unfashionable...SO uncool in today’s' lets make a deal environment,
and I'm not in any way bad rapping that critical side of our
business...but the front line of programming needs a heart. We must
bleed XM colors....cry at the magic of a great song (or break),
program for the people, live and breathe art, move forward with fist
clenching intensity and desire to win through brilliance and
imagination. Funny thing is that as un-Wall Street as that might be,
that sort of thinking will deliver the kind of radio that XM needs to
win the war. Think and program like an artist. A smart artist. Kinda
like Springsteen. Uncompromising. He just "Does it". An American
Original...........

CAMP: XM must celebrate life in North America. The good, the bad and
the ugly. That's why we love TV themes, old commercials, homeless guys
doing promos, heavily accented people doing IDs, bagpipes in bumpers.
Celebrate America by DELIVERING THE SOUND OF NORTH AMERICA.

ANTICIPATION: There is ALWAYS something coming up on XM. We program
forward.


SELLING: Sell the Music...sell the programming...sell the specials,
etc...Selling is a lost art.
I'm not talking about selling Used Cars...I'm talking about ridding
ourselves of the Radio Inferiority Complex and selling the ---- out of
the cool stuff we're doing. This isn't bragging, because bragging is
generic, bordering on lying. Selling is talkin' it up and DELIVERING.
If we sell AND deliver, credibility will occur!

This is a mission...not a gig.





Yet I fear (as this reader comment details) XM will be forced into
medocrity to compete with sirius.





Anonymous said...

All of this sounds great, but very little of it is happening at
XM. You've dropped the great niche channels like WorldZone, duplicated
the hits channels offered by Clear Channel which is a total waste, and
over-channeled the system so the sound quality has decreased
dramatically.

Have you actually listened to XM with headphones lately? How long
does it take for you to get a headache? When you switch between MP3s
and XM content on the Inno, the XM sound seems like it's playing
through a bath towel.

Please wake up and listen to the reality of XM's programming and
sound quality in mid-2006 versus the fantasy of what you're writing in
your amusing blog.

Stop trying to win the battle with Sirius by having the MOST music
and instead try to have the BEST music -- in diversity of genres and
superior sound quality.


GS

All My Shrimp Was Dead and Gone
June 8th, 2006, 09:30 AM
I think there is a certain truth to this reply -- while the SQ issues are
valid, for most people, they just don't matter. Other than a few on these
boards, I've yet to run in to anyone who cares. When I want variety (most
of the time), I listen to XM -- when I want better SQ, I listen to my IPod
thru REAL headphones or my home system. Reality: Most people listening to
IPods are listening through Earbuds which provide almost nonexistent sound
quality anyway. People just don't give a ----.

But the programming issue is true. Since the March 1 changes, XM's
programming has definitely declined in an effort to "dumb-it-down" to SIRI's
level. XM's is, to be sure, still far superior to Sirius (particularly in
the music area) there is little doubt that it was better before the change.

XM needs to return to the content formula that was working, leaving it
lightyears ahead of SIRI's programming. And they need to make a big deal
about it.

There may be some change coming (here is another blogger's remarks):

XM has the greatest service known to man and the only people who know it are
its subscribers.

Used to be that satellite radio was new, a NOVELTY! But once Howard Stern
hit the front page of "The New York Times" satellite radio became Coldplay.
The new thing that EVERYBODY had heard of.

I know I've been beating the service up. And it deserved it. Because of
Zellner's misguided programming initiatives. Gutting the SOUL of XM, making
it more like terrestrial, by CUTTING THE PLAYLISTS! But I've been assured
those days are through. And I believe it. Based on the back hall
conversations I had all day. Of lifers (since 2000!) telling me they weren't
going to budge. They're like the North Vietnamese. They're NEVER going to
give in.

The Eagles sing we haven't had that spirit here since 1969? Well seemingly
everybody who felt it back then is working at XM. PASSIONATELY! The zeal is
what translates. This isn't a job, this is a CALLING! People have been
working seven days a week for FIVE YEARS! Because they believe. And you
might believe too. If XM's marketing wasn't so goddamn awful.

Satellite radio is no longer an indie band. It's on a major now. Used to be
that when you told someone about XM, they had no idea what it was. You MADE
them listen. Now bring up the outlet and you get a shrug. How do you convert
these people? How do you make them believers? That's the question. Which has
gone completely unaddressed at XM.

Sirius is employing a star strategy. Emanating enough sizzle that if you're
interested in buying a radio you're going to go with them, not XM. After
all, everybody wants to align with a winner. And if you don't think Sirius
is the satellite radio leader, you've got your head up your ass.

They wouldn't acknowledge this in the XM building. They wanted to quote
financials, statistics. But it's not about statistics, it's about
PERCEPTION! And the perception is that Sirius is where it's happening. When
it's not really that way at all.

Go to Sirius. You feel the buzz. The CORPORATE buzz. Everybody's dressed up.
After all, they're in Manhattan. In a high rise. Whereas hanging at XM is
like going backstage. And if you don't think EVERY concert attendee wants to
go backstage, you're so fucking jaded you can stop reading now.

People want to feel close. Like they belong. Like they're a MEMBER of
something. There's membership evidenced in Howard Stern's show, hell, that's
what it's all ABOUT! But the rest of Sirius? Except for Little Steven's
Underground Garage you can take and leave the channels. Oh, they're better
than terrestrial, there's no commercials on the music channels, but they've
got no SOUL! And soul is a key element of belief.

I wish I had a video of Lee Abrams explaining his programming chart. It's
got four axes. Analog to digital and culturally-aware to unaware. Use
cliches, have contests, play the obvious tracks on the stations appealing to
the aware and you lose them. God, the adult listener doesn't want to WIN the
album, he'll BUY it, if he likes what he hears. So why are all the music
stations I listen to on Sirius directed towards a theoretical listener who
doesn't only not exist, but whom I'd hate if I ever met. I don't want to be
a member of that club. Sirius is America. A dumbed-down server of pabulum
trying to capture EVERYBODY in the big tent and ultimately nailing, making
BELIEVERS, of none.

But you don't know this unless you've listened to both services. Which only
pros have done. Both XM and Sirius listeners think they've reached nirvana,
but for different reasons. Sirius subscribers are just thrilled to have
something better than terrestrial, whereas XM listeners have seen God.

God is Eddie Kilroy.

----, I know nothing about country music, real country music. And that's all
that Eddie Kilroy plays on Hank's Place. Nobody autotunes THESE stars. And
they're stars not because they've sold a zillion records, but because
they've made GREAT MUSIC!

Oh, in his Texas drawl Eddie told me about going to Nashville with forty
bucks in his pocket. About making less working in radio than his rent but
his boss refusing to give him a raise. Having a hit record running Playboy
Records. No wonder Willie Nelson constantly drops in, Eddie Kilroy is the
REAL DEAL! I'm gonna listen to Hank's Place now just to hear his stories.
The kind they'd make a Lifetime series about, if Lifetime were for guys
instead of girls.

Then there was this guy Ken Smith, who runs the fifties. Like everybody else
in the building Ken wouldn't shut up. I didn't even have to put a dime in
the jukebox. He just wanted to tell his story, to EVERYBODY! Turn everybody
on to great music, the ROOTS of rock and roll. And not only the hits, but
the album cuts.

Then there was Bobby Bennett, majordomo of Soul Street. The wannabe baseball
player with distinct rules about what fit on his station and what didn't. If
it had disco elements, it was TOO LATE! And even if it appealed to whites,
like the Flamingos, if it was R&B, if it was good, he played it.

The talk at Sirius is all about business. The talk at XM is all about music.
And for geeks like us, it's heaven.

But let me tell you, everybody's a geek. Everybody wants to hear more good
music. It just has to be filtered and SOLD properly. Which is what XM jocks
do.

But nobody knows. Hell, I've had XM for YEARS and had no idea who Eddie
Kilroy was. But does the channel promote this asset? No, it signs Oprah for
millions when she'll barely be on the station. We hear about Derek Jeter
when talk turns to the Yankees, why do we never hear about Mike Marrone? Or
George Taylor Morris? The XM PLAYERS?? There's all this hype about hardware,
yet content isn't even given lip service. HOW WRONGHEADED!

You can't find a single soul punching the clock at XM. It's the way the
record business used to be. But it's in D.C. Hell, might as well be on a
ship in the Atlantic. Yes, XM is a pirate station. Sold as a luxury liner.
And people can't hook onto a cruise ship holding thousands, but tell them
you've got a cabin just for them on a small boat and they're THERE!

Oh, there's a vibe at Sirius. Maybe because they're on the ball in all the
ways that XM isn't. They're into sizzle, saving the service, throwing the
long ball. It's a BUSINESS story. But it's not a music story. XM's a music
story.

The Zellner era is over. The original vision has been restored. XM wants to
save your soul. If only they'd convey the message. If only people like me
didn't have to do it for them.

Hell, their whole AUDIENCE would do it for them if they mobilized their
listeners. Made the service appear underground. Form the equivalent of
street teams. After all, people believe in XM MORE than the lame bands being
purveyed by the music industry. But no, it's all a Wall Street story. Let's
placate our investors.

Isn't this how America got fucked up to begin with? Isn't this how Japan
kicked our ass in cars and so many other areas? By going for short term
profits instead of having vision and holding on, waiting for the great hit
to land in the stands?

Less than a decade ago, Apple Computer was a joke. Steve Jobs was an
arrogant has-been. Now Apple was on everybody's lips at the "Wall Street
Journal's" D Conference even though Apple had no presence. Steve Jobs is the
most admired businessman in America. Did this happen by playing Wall
Street's game? No, it was a result of having really cool products and
marketing the hell out of them! XM was so fucked up that they felt they
could solve their problems by making the product LESS cool, playing FEWER
tunes. But it's cool once again. Where's the Think Different campaign? Where
are the iPod imaging ads? Where's the establishment of a club, even though
it's a mainstream product? God, ever notice that iPod users are a CULT? Even
though the device has over 70% of the market? There's a way to do this. To
grow XM's cult without fucking it up. It's not through the Inno, other
flawed hardware. It's via radio that is so cool, so meaningful, that not
only can't you live a day without it, but you can't wait until you wake up
in the morning so you can turn it back on.

--

If you would like to subscribe to the LefsetzLetter,

http://www.lefsetz.com/lists/?p=subscribe&id=1

David
June 8th, 2006, 12:30 PM
On Thu, 08 Jun 2006 14:58:56 GMT, "All My Shrimp Was Dead and Gone"
<DeadShrimp@NOMail.com> wrote:

Goddam. Fresh batch of krank on the East Coast or what?

This is fucking radio. Not church. Not philosophy class.

Do ---- that sounds interesting, keep your ears to the ground,
remember the talent's on the fucking record.

GS
June 9th, 2006, 06:30 PM
Obviously you prefer Sirius to XM... nuff said.

GS

On Thu, 08 Jun 2006 17:58:04 GMT, David <rickets@knac.com> wrote:

>On Thu, 08 Jun 2006 14:58:56 GMT, "All My Shrimp Was Dead and Gone"
><DeadShrimp@NOMail.com> wrote:
>
>Goddam. Fresh batch of krank on the East Coast or what?
>
>This is fucking radio. Not church. Not philosophy class.
>
> Do ---- that sounds interesting, keep your ears to the ground,
>remember the talent's on the fucking record.

David
June 9th, 2006, 07:30 PM
On Fri, 09 Jun 2006 16:30:18 -0700, GS <GS@nospam.net> wrote:

>Obviously you prefer Sirius to XM... nuff said.
>
>GS

''Nuff''?

I didn't always prefer Sirius to XM. XM lost the advantage with me
when they -----canned MusicLab, an act which pretty much proves that
Lee Abrams' flowery prose is BS.

'nough said.

All My Shrimp Was Dead and Gone
June 9th, 2006, 08:30 PM
>
> I didn't always prefer Sirius to XM. XM lost the advantage with me
> when they -----canned MusicLab, an act which pretty much proves that
> Lee Abrams' flowery prose is BS.
>

Musiclab was absolute garbage. They knew it and so did everyone else.
That's why it was ----canned.

Remember, not EVERYONE is on acid 4 nites a week like you ...

David
June 9th, 2006, 09:30 PM
On Sat, 10 Jun 2006 02:04:47 GMT, "All My Shrimp Was Dead and Gone"
<DeadShrimp@NOMail.com> wrote:


>>
>
>Musiclab was absolute garbage. They knew it and so did everyone else.
>That's why it was ----canned.
>
Remember, like you EVERYONE is not on acid 4 nites a week ...
>
>

GS
June 10th, 2006, 11:30 AM
Yes, and I started with Sirius and was disgusted with their commercial
radio approach to what I thought was supposed to be different... and
switched to XM. (I also had to buy two 50' extension cables to get
the antenna into a place of clear enough sky where the weak Sirius
signal did not drop out all the time.)

As I said... different strokes for different folks. I come from a more
adult, public radio background, and you come from a commercial FM
background. I am happy there are two services so that we can both have
what we prefer.

'nuff said?

GS

P.S. As to music lab... (ch 51) it sucked. Not including "The Dead" on
a "jam band channel" is like leaving Bill Monroe off the bluegrass
channel. I really tried to get into music lab, but it was BAD.



On Sat, 10 Jun 2006 00:44:48 GMT, David <rickets@knac.com> wrote:

>On Fri, 09 Jun 2006 16:30:18 -0700, GS <GS@nospam.net> wrote:
>
>>Obviously you prefer Sirius to XM... nuff said.
>>
>>GS
>
>''Nuff''?
>
>I didn't always prefer Sirius to XM. XM lost the advantage with me
>when they -----canned MusicLab, an act which pretty much proves that
>Lee Abrams' flowery prose is BS.
>
>'nough said.

David
June 10th, 2006, 01:30 PM
On Sat, 10 Jun 2006 10:03:10 -0700, GS <GS@nospam.net> wrote:

>Yes, and I started with Sirius and was disgusted with their commercial
>radio approach to what I thought was supposed to be different... and
>switched to XM. (I also had to buy two 50' extension cables to get
>the antenna into a place of clear enough sky where the weak Sirius
>signal did not drop out all the time.)
>
>As I said... different strokes for different folks. I come from a more
>adult, public radio background, and you come from a commercial FM
>background. I am happy there are two services so that we can both have
>what we prefer.
>
>'nuff said?
>
>GS
>
>P.S. As to music lab... (ch 51) it sucked. Not including "The Dead" on
>a "jam band channel" is like leaving Bill Monroe off the bluegrass
>channel. I really tried to get into music lab, but it was BAD.
>
>
You know nothing about me. I am a veteran major market NCE, eclectric
format pioneer, radio program director. I got ribbons.

There is nothing ''adult'' about your sweeping generalizations and
your inability to recognize evolution. While you may wish to pretend
that XM's willingness to mix the ''bubbling under'' stuff with the
proven product indicates ''depth'' I disagree. Sure, there's plenty
of great stuff that never charts, but it ain't the Sensational Alex
Harvey Band and it ain't the flip side of ''White Bird''. It's the
kind of stuff that MusicLab originally played like Gentle Giant and
Brand X. Once they started mixing in the Jam Band crap all was lost.
2 genres that would ony appear related to someone who knows nothing
about either.

If XM wants to do deep tracks, keep 'em on Deep Tracks. Once upon a
time 46 was 100% up-tempo stadium rock. Start the motor, pop the
clutch, let's go. But now? Clue: ''American Pie'' ain't classic
rock.

Meanwhile, up in NYC, Sirius researches and researches some more.
They log requests, they tweak. They have stations with tight lists
and have stations where the jocks ad lib. If you don't care enough to
feel your way around you end up making blanket generalizations like
above.

Here's a cliche' for you: Bottom line; when I have to pick one or
the other for a long drive, Sirius wins, because I'm afraid XM will
put me to sleep.

Barry Delfino
June 10th, 2006, 07:30 PM
"David" <rickets@knac.com> wrote in message
news:7t5m82d4scets607m67bhpgu4vmfqfqegd@4ax.com...
> Harvey Band and it ain't the flip side of ''White Bird''. It's the
> kind of stuff that MusicLab originally played like Gentle Giant and

Ahh...yes, yes, yes. Some "Free Hand", anyone? Or perhaps something from "In
A Glass House" would better suit you?

A great band, GG.

GS
June 10th, 2006, 08:31 PM
I don't know why you need to be so confrontational or so insecure you
need to pat yourself on the back so much. I am sure your ribbons are
great... people get ribbons for all kinds of things... even 4th and
5th place. I am glad you are so proud of your ribbons.

Anyway, regardless of your "qualifications" , if you like Sirius and
obviously your ribbons make your opinion more valuable then mine, that
is great... good for you.

My point is that not everyone likes the same thing. Some people find
the repetition and endless commercial radio oriented jingles
interrupting the sets to be undesirable. XM is for them.

It is cool that you like that kind of stuff and you have found a place
where you can hear it. So, for sure Sirius is for you.

Fortunately I can have what I like too... I hope that is ok with you
even though I don't have ribbons to validate my opinions.... (sigh).

'nuff said!

GS



On Sat, 10 Jun 2006 19:21:32 GMT, David <rickets@knac.com> wrote:

> I am a veteran major market NCE, eclectric
>format pioneer, radio program director. I got ribbons.

David
June 11th, 2006, 08:30 AM
On Sat, 10 Jun 2006 19:12:11 -0700, GS <GS@nospam.net> wrote:

>I don't know why you need to be so confrontational or so insecure you
>need to pat yourself on the back so much. I am sure your ribbons are
>great... people get ribbons for all kinds of things... even 4th and
>5th place. I am glad you are so proud of your ribbons.
>
>Anyway, regardless of your "qualifications" , if you like Sirius and
>obviously your ribbons make your opinion more valuable then mine, that
>is great... good for you.
>
>My point is that not everyone likes the same thing. Some people find
>the repetition and endless commercial radio oriented jingles
>interrupting the sets to be undesirable. XM is for them.
>
>It is cool that you like that kind of stuff and you have found a place
>where you can hear it. So, for sure Sirius is for you.
>
>Fortunately I can have what I like too... I hope that is ok with you
>even though I don't have ribbons to validate my opinions.... (sigh).
>
>'nuff said!
>
Jingles? Do you even know what a jingle is?

You speak like Sirius' channels are all identical. I say to you that
there is a variety of approaches and to blanketly condemn based on a
flawed perception is spreading bad information.

(Is ''nuff said'' your trademark?)

GS
June 11th, 2006, 09:30 AM
Like I said, I used to have Sirius and switched to XM. I like it much
better. You like Sirius. Good for you.

Obviously we are not going to agree on the reasons, so lets just call
it personal choice and leave it there... ok?

We thankfully have two different satellite radio services. They have
different formats. Some like "A" some like "B". I do not understand
why so many on this newsgroup that like "A" or "B" insist on making
those that like something different wrong or bad.

enough said yet??????

GS



On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 14:17:57 GMT, David <rickets@knac.com> wrote:
>Jingles? Do you even know what a jingle is?
>
>You speak like Sirius' channels are all identical. I say to you that
>there is a variety of approaches and to blanketly condemn based on a
>flawed perception is spreading bad information.
>
>(Is ''nuff said'' your trademark?)

David
June 11th, 2006, 09:30 AM
On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 08:20:16 -0700, GS <GS@nospam.net> wrote:

>Like I said, I used to have Sirius and switched to XM. I like it much
>better. You like Sirius. Good for you.
>
>Obviously we are not going to agree on the reasons, so lets just call
>it personal choice and leave it there... ok?
>
>We thankfully have two different satellite radio services. They have
>different formats. Some like "A" some like "B". I do not understand
>why so many on this newsgroup that like "A" or "B" insist on making
>those that like something different wrong or bad.
>
>enough said yet??????
>
I subscribe to both. I prefer Sirius slightly better because it
sounds better in my pickup truck and is less likely to put me to
sleep.

Did you listen to Disorder when you had Sirius?

GS
June 11th, 2006, 10:30 AM
Yes, we liked Sirius Disorder very much... and I also liked their now
gone folk town ch 38, and the jam band channel 17... but as I said, my
preference is for uninterrupted sets, and the ID's, jingles, bumpers
(or whatever you want to call them) Sirius placed between nearly every
song was VERY irritating to me. XM has these too, but on the channels
we listen to, there are much fewer and they are far less obnoxious.

Sirius also had quite a few channels with motor mouth announcers, and
they often talked over the songs, which I also find undesirable.

The only way I can describe it is one satellite service sounded more
like commercial radio without the ads and one sounds more like
non-commercial, public radio.

I had an e-mail conversation With Adam Foley from Jam on ch 17 about
this and he was frustrated too. I will paste that at the end of this.

GS


On 1/12/2005, "SIRIUS" wrote:

>Channel : Jam_ON, 17
>Name : GS
>Email :
>On-air Host : Adam Foley
>Message : THANK YOU for not talking excessively (unlike most Sirius anouncers),
>playing multiple songs in a row (sets) without interruption and not playing so many of the
>annoying channel ID jingles!

Adam Foley <adam@foleyweb.com> wrote:

Thanks man, I'm pretty self-conscious about those things. I still have
to play some of that ----, but I do what I can.

Those decisions are made at a way higher level than the program
director (my direct boss), but I agree 100% and I'm going to forward
it on to him. I'm sure nothing will come of it, but maybe if they get
enough messages like this they'll rethink their strategy.

Adam






On Sun, 11 Jun 2006 15:24:31 GMT, David <rickets@knac.com> wrote:

>Did you listen to Disorder when you had Sirius?